Bay Shore NY
211 active listings out of 18K total properties we track across 12 Bay Shore ZIPs — listings, off-market homes, rentals, and full sales/tax history. Refreshed nightly.
While you're here, take in the bigger picture — maps below show New York (statewide), not just Bay Shore. Same company, same dataset, different resolution.
Inventory breakdown
Distribution of the 211 currently-active listings in Bay Shore, NY. Full dataset covers 18K properties — listings, off-market homes, rentals, and full history.
ZIP codes in Bay Shore
Drill into any ZIP for hex-level breakdowns.
Nearby cities
Other New York cities within driving distance.
Get Bay Shore, NY data in your app
GET https://api.straply.com/v1/markets/city/bay-shore-ny
Authorization: Bearer $STRAPLY_KEY{
"city": "bay-shore-ny",
"total_tracked": 18401,
"active": 211,
"median_list": 639000
}Bay Shore, NY real estate: market summary
As of April 2026, Straply tracks 18,401 homes in Bay Shore, NY, with 211 active for sale at a median list price of $639,000 (~$419/sq ft). Notably, most homes were built in the 1950s.
- Median list price
- $639,000
- Median $/sq ft
- $419
- Active listings
- 211
- Median sale price
- $615,000 (-8% YoY)
- Properties tracked
- 18,401
Frequently asked: Bay Shore, NY real estate
What is the median home price in Bay Shore?
The median list price in Bay Shore, NY is $639,000 (about $419 per square foot), based on 211 active listings tracked by Straply as of April 2026.
What price range are homes in Bay Shore?
Active listings in Bay Shore, NY concentrate in: 53% $500k–$750k and 14% $750k–$1m.
Are home prices in Bay Shore going up or down?
The median sale price is $615,000, down 8% year over year. Straply tracked 406 sales here over the past 12 months.
How many homes are for sale in Bay Shore?
Straply is tracking 211 active listings in Bay Shore, NY out of 18,401 properties on record as of April 2026.
How old are the homes in Bay Shore?
Most homes in Bay Shore, NY were built in the 1950s. About 18% were built after 1980, while 10% predate 1940. The newest tracked home dates to 2026.
What types of homes are in Bay Shore?
Bay Shore, NY is mostly single-family homes (83% of listings). Also common: condos 10%.
How many bedrooms do homes in Bay Shore typically have?
The most common size in Bay Shore, NY is 3 bd.
What are the most active ZIP codes in Bay Shore?
The ZIP codes with the most active listings in Bay Shore, NY are 11706, 11770.
What areas are near Bay Shore?
Nearby markets Straply also tracks include Brightwaters, Islip, West Islip, North Babylon.
Data as of April 2026. Source: Straply. For address-level history and programmatic access, use the Straply API.