Real Estate Data API

Shelter Island NY

103 active listings out of 2.7K total properties we track across 2 Shelter Island ZIPs — listings, off-market homes, rentals, and full sales/tax history. Refreshed nightly.

Get this data → API docs
Active
103
Median
$2.5M
±0%
Sales (12mo)
32
Tracked
2.7K
Zoomed out

While you're here, take in the bigger picture — maps below show New York (statewide), not just Shelter Island. Same company, same dataset, different resolution.

Get this data →
Get this data →
Get this data →
Get this data →
Get this data →

Inventory breakdown

Distribution of the 103 currently-active listings in Shelter Island, NY. Full dataset covers 2.7K properties — listings, off-market homes, rentals, and full history.

Active by price range
Under $300K 0 (0%)
$300K–$500K 1 (1%)
$500K–$750K 2 (2%)
$750K–$1M 3 (2.9%)
$1M–$2M 34 (33.3%)
$2M+ 62 (60.8%)
Active by bedroom count
Studio/1 bd 5
2 bd 6
3 bd 32
4 bd 29
5+ bd 31
Active by property type
Single Family 99 (96.1%)
Condo 3 (2.9%)
Lot 1 (1%)

ZIP codes in Shelter Island

Drill into any ZIP for hex-level breakdowns.

11964
→
Active
102
Tracked
2.6K
11965
→
Active
1
Tracked
111

Nearby cities

Other New York cities within driving distance.

Shelter Island Heights
0.5 mi away
Active: 30
Southold
4.1 mi away
Active: 76
East Marion
4.2 mi away
Active: 26
Sag Harbor
5.3 mi away
Active: 272
Peconic
6.3 mi away
Active: 6
Orient
6.5 mi away
Active: 23
Bridgehampton
8.7 mi away
Active: 67
Wainscott
9.4 mi away
Active: 36
For Developers

Get Shelter Island, NY data in your app

curl
request 
GET https://api.straply.com/v1/markets/city/shelter-island-ny
Authorization: Bearer $STRAPLY_KEY
200 OK response 
{
  "city": "shelter-island-ny",
  "total_tracked": 2693,
  "active": 103,
  "median_list": 2497500
}
Get an API key Read the docs

Shelter Island, NY real estate: market summary

As of April 2026, Straply tracks 2,693 homes in Shelter Island, NY, with 103 active for sale at a median list price of $2,497,500 (~$1,031/sq ft). Notably, it's a high-end market — 33% of recent sales were $1M or more.

Median list price
$2,497,500
Median $/sq ft
$1,031
Active listings
103
Properties tracked
2,693

Frequently asked: Shelter Island, NY real estate

What is the median home price in Shelter Island?

The median list price in Shelter Island, NY is $2,497,500 (about $1,031 per square foot), based on 103 active listings tracked by Straply as of April 2026.

What price range are homes in Shelter Island?

Active listings in Shelter Island, NY concentrate in: 61% $2m+ and 33% $1m–$2m.

How many homes are for sale in Shelter Island?

Straply is tracking 103 active listings in Shelter Island, NY out of 2,693 properties on record as of April 2026.

How old are the homes in Shelter Island?

Most homes in Shelter Island, NY were built in the 1980s. About 44% were built after 1980, while 20% predate 1940. The newest tracked home dates to 2026.

What types of homes are in Shelter Island?

Shelter Island, NY is mostly single-family homes (96% of listings).

How many bedrooms do homes in Shelter Island typically have?

The most common size in Shelter Island, NY is 3 bd.

What are the most active ZIP codes in Shelter Island?

The ZIP codes with the most active listings in Shelter Island, NY are 11964, 11965.

What areas are near Shelter Island?

Nearby markets Straply also tracks include Shelter Island Heights, Southold, East Marion, Sag Harbor.

Data as of April 2026. Source: Straply. For address-level history and programmatic access, use the Straply API.